San Diego's Great Housing Reset: Rents Fall for First Time in 15 Years as Market Enters New Era
TL;DR: The Great Housing Reset Has Arrived in San Diego
For the first time in 15 years, San Diego rents are falling—down for 6 consecutive months. Home prices have declined for 5 straight months. Redfin and Compass call it the "Great Housing Reset"—a multi-year recalibration where wage growth finally outpaces housing costs. For sellers, this means fewer qualified buyers, longer listing times, but also greater value in cash offers that eliminate appraisal risk and financing contingencies. The market you knew is gone. Here's what comes next.
Real estate giants Redfin and Compass are calling it "The Great Housing Reset"—and San Diego is ground zero. For the first time in 15 years, rents are falling across San Diego County. Combine that with five straight months of home price declines, and you have a market transformation that's rewriting the rules for buyers and sellers alike.
If you're a San Diego homeowner wondering whether now is the right time to sell, or if you should wait for the market to stabilize, understanding this historic shift is critical. The Great Housing Reset isn't just another market cycle—it's a fundamental recalibration that creates both challenges and opportunities.
What Is the Great Housing Reset?
According to Redfin's 2026 housing forecast, the Great Housing Reset represents "a yearslong period of gradual increases in home sales and normalization of prices as affordability gradually improves." Unlike the sharp corrections of past downturns, this reset is characterized by a slow rebalancing where wage growth finally outpaces home price appreciation.
For the first time since the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, homebuyers will see their purchasing power increase as incomes rise faster than housing costs. Redfin predicts that home prices nationally will rise just 1% year-over-year in 2026, while wages are expected to grow at a faster pace—creating the first sustained period of improving affordability in over 15 years.
But what makes San Diego's situation particularly noteworthy is the dual pressure: both rents and home prices are declining simultaneously, a rare occurrence that signals a significant market inflection point.
Historic Milestone: 6-Month Rental Decline—First Time Since 2010
San Diego County rents have fallen for six consecutive months, marking the first sustained rental decline in 15 years, according to data reported by the San Diego Union-Tribune. While the decreases have been incremental, the trend is unmistakable: average rents have dropped to $2,520, down 0.3% year-over-year.
This is particularly significant when you consider that San Diego rents have been climbing relentlessly since 2010. The last time rents fell on an annualized basis was during the aftermath of the Great Recession, when vacancy rates spiked and landlords competed aggressively for tenants.
What's driving this historic decline? According to real estate data from CoStar, vacancy rates have climbed from a historic low of 2.7% at the end of 2021 to 5.9%—the highest level seen in 15 years. This increase in available units has shifted negotiating power from landlords to renters.
The Supply Side Story
The rental decline isn't happening in a vacuum. San Diego is experiencing an apartment construction boom, with approximately 4,800 new apartments projected to come online in both 2025 and 2026. According to Northmarq research, nearly 4,300 units have already been completed—surpassing total annual deliveries recorded in 2024.
Major projects reshaping San Diego's housing supply include:
Midway Rising
The massive $3.9 billion redevelopment of San Diego's sports arena property plans to deliver more than 4,200 apartment units—2,000 of which would be rent-capped for qualifying residents. If approved by the City Council in early 2026, construction could begin by late 2026, making this potentially the largest affordable housing project in California history.
101 Ash Street Conversion
Downtown San Diego's long-vacant 101 Ash Street office building is being transformed into 247 affordable housing units, with construction anticipated to begin in spring 2026. This 21-story office-to-residential conversion represents a growing trend of repurposing underutilized commercial space.
Across neighborhoods from Downtown to Pacific Beach, Golden Hill to University Heights, new apartment buildings are adding thousands of units to the rental market. This influx of supply is directly contributing to the rental price softening we're seeing.
Simultaneous Home Price Decline: Five Months of Falling Values
While rents decline, home prices are following a similar trajectory. According to the latest Case-Shiller Home Price Index data, San Diego home prices declined 0.10% in October 2026—marking the sixth consecutive monthly decline. Year-over-year, San Diego prices are down 0.59% locally, even as national prices rose 1.36%.
The San Diego Union-Tribune reported this as a "stark reversal from the pandemic boom," when bidding wars and rapid appreciation were the norm. San Diego now joins cities like Atlanta, Dallas, Denver, Las Vegas, Miami, and Phoenix in experiencing year-over-year home price declines.
S&P Dow Jones Indices, which produces the Case-Shiller data, suggests the market is reaching a "new equilibrium" as elevated mortgage rates and persistent inflation create affordability pressures that limit buyer demand.
The Mortgage Rate Reality
A critical factor constraining traditional homebuyers is mortgage rates. As of January 2026, 30-year fixed-rate mortgages are averaging 6.22%, according to Freddie Mac data. While this represents an improvement from the 7%+ rates seen in early 2025, it's still significantly higher than the sub-3% rates that fueled the pandemic housing boom.
Forecasters predict that rates will gradually decline toward 6.0% by Q4 2026, with some optimistic projections suggesting they could reach the high 5% range if inflation continues moderating. However, even at 6%, monthly payments remain substantially higher than they were just three years ago.
For a median-priced San Diego home at $950,000, the difference between a 3% and a 6% mortgage rate adds approximately $1,600 to the monthly payment—pushing many would-be buyers to the sidelines.
Why Industry Leaders Are Declaring a New Era
Both Redfin and Compass, two of the nation's largest real estate brokerages, have declared that 2026 marks the beginning of a new housing era. But why the optimism amidst falling prices and rents?
The answer lies in what's been broken in the housing market for years: affordability. According to Redfin's analysis, the Great Housing Reset will take about five years for the housing market to return to normal, "as housing costs soared much faster than earnings during the pandemic."
Key indicators supporting this optimistic reset narrative:
- Wage Growth Outpacing Home Prices: For the first time since the financial crisis, incomes are rising faster than housing costs, gradually improving affordability.
- Inventory Normalization: Home listings are increasing as the "lock-in effect" from low pandemic-era mortgage rates gradually diminishes.
- Rental Market Softening: Falling rents provide relief for cost-burdened renters while also reducing the opportunity cost of homeownership.
- New Supply Coming Online: Regulatory changes and major development projects are adding significant housing supply across California.
- Declining Mortgage Rates: The gradual descent from 7%+ rates to 6% and potentially lower provides meaningful payment relief.
What the Great Housing Reset Means for San Diego Neighborhoods
The impact of the housing reset varies significantly by neighborhood:
Coastal Communities (Pacific Beach, La Jolla, Point Loma)
Premium coastal areas remain relatively insulated, with La Jolla median home prices at $2.8 million and Pacific Beach at approximately $1.3 million. However, even these markets are seeing extended listing times and fewer bidding wars. Rental properties in Pacific Beach averaging $3,500/month for two-bedrooms are experiencing increased vacancy rates as new supply comes online.
Urban Core (Downtown, Golden Hill, University Heights)
Downtown San Diego and adjacent neighborhoods are ground zero for office-to-housing conversions and high-density development. The 101 Ash Street conversion, Midway Rising project, and numerous apartment buildings under construction are dramatically increasing supply. Landlords in these areas are facing the most pressure to reduce rents and offer concessions.
Investment Property Hot Spots (Ocean Beach, Normal Heights, City Heights)
Neighborhoods popular with rental property investors are experiencing a strategic inflection point. With rents falling for the first time in 15 years and property values stabilizing or declining, investors must recalculate return-on-investment assumptions that may no longer hold.
Cash Buyer Advantage in Market Reset Conditions
During periods of market uncertainty and reset, cash buyers offer distinct advantages that become increasingly valuable:
Cash Buyer Benefits:
- Speed and Certainty: Traditional financed buyers face multiple contingencies—loan approval, appraisal, inspection, potential re-negotiation. Cash buyers eliminate financing contingencies entirely.
- No Appraisal Gap Risk: In a declining market, the home you agree to sell for $800,000 today might appraise for $780,000 when the buyer's lender orders the appraisal 30 days later.
- Faster Closing Timeline: Traditional sales take 30-60 days minimum. Cash transactions can close in as little as 7-14 days.
- Flexibility on Condition: Cash buyers typically purchase properties as-is, eliminating the need for costly repairs or price reductions.
Action Steps for San Diego Homeowners
If you're a San Diego homeowner trying to navigate the Great Housing Reset, consider these steps:
- Get a Current Market Analysis: Understand what your home is actually worth in today's market, not what it was worth six months ago.
- Evaluate Your Motivation: Are you selling because you want to, or because circumstances require it? Your timeline affects your strategy.
- Consider Your Alternatives: What are your options if you don't sell now? What happens if prices decline another 3-5% over the next 12 months?
- Understand Your Tax Situation: Consult with a tax advisor about the implications of selling this year versus next, especially for investment properties.
- Explore Cash Buyer Options: Even if you list traditionally, knowing your cash buyer alternatives provides valuable information and a backup plan.
- Be Realistic About Pricing: In a reset market, overpricing leads to extended listing times and stale listings that ultimately sell for less.
- Monitor Local Development: Major projects like Midway Rising and ongoing apartment construction will continue affecting neighborhood dynamics.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Great Housing Reset?
The Great Housing Reset is a term coined by Redfin to describe the housing market transition beginning in 2026, where wage growth outpaces home price appreciation for the first time since the 2008 financial crisis. It represents a multi-year period of gradual affordability improvement as prices normalize and incomes catch up to housing costs that surged during the pandemic.
When did San Diego rents last fall?
San Diego rents are falling for the first time since 2010. Rents have declined for six consecutive months through late 2025, marking the first sustained rental decline in 15 years. The last time San Diego experienced falling rents on an annualized basis was during the aftermath of the Great Recession in 2010.
Why are San Diego rents falling in 2026?
San Diego rents are falling due to a significant increase in apartment supply and rising vacancy rates. Approximately 4,800 new apartments are coming online in both 2025 and 2026, causing vacancy rates to climb from a historic low of 2.7% in 2021 to 5.9%—the highest level in 15 years. This increased supply has shifted negotiating power from landlords to renters.
How long have San Diego home prices been declining?
San Diego home prices have declined for six consecutive months according to the Case-Shiller Home Price Index, with the October 2026 data showing a 0.10% monthly decline and a 0.59% year-over-year decrease. This contrasts with national home prices, which rose 1.36% over the same period.
Should I sell my San Diego home now or wait for the market to improve?
The decision depends on your personal circumstances and timeline. If you need to sell due to relocation, financial circumstances, or life changes, waiting may not be practical. Consider that markets can take years to recover after a reset, and attempting to time the market perfectly is difficult. If you choose to sell, cash buyers offer certainty and speed that can be valuable in uncertain market conditions.
What is the Midway Rising project?
Midway Rising is a $3.9 billion redevelopment of San Diego's sports arena property planned to include more than 4,200 apartment units (2,000 of which would be rent-capped affordable housing), a new arena, retail, and entertainment venues. If approved by City Council in early 2026, construction could begin by late 2026, making it potentially the largest affordable housing project in California history.
How do cash buyers help during a housing market reset?
Cash buyers provide several advantages during market uncertainty: (1) No financing contingencies that can fall through, (2) No appraisal risk in a declining market where values may come in lower than contract price, (3) Faster closing timelines of 7-14 days versus 30-60 days for traditional sales, (4) As-is purchases eliminating repair negotiations, and (5) Certainty of closing that lets sellers move forward with their plans rather than riding out continued market volatility.
Which San Diego neighborhoods are most affected by the housing reset?
Urban core neighborhoods like Downtown, Golden Hill, and University Heights are experiencing the most significant impact due to major apartment construction and office-to-housing conversions. Coastal communities like Pacific Beach, La Jolla, and Point Loma remain relatively insulated but are seeing extended listing times. Investment property hot spots like Ocean Beach, Normal Heights, and City Heights are seeing rental income assumptions challenged by declining rents.
Get Your Free Cash Offer Today
If you're considering selling your San Diego home and want the certainty of a guaranteed closing without financing contingencies, listing hassles, or extended market exposure, San Diego Fast Cash Home Buyer can help.
We provide free, no-obligation cash offers with closing in as little as 7-14 days. No repairs, no showings, no uncertainty—just a straightforward transaction that lets you move forward with confidence.
The Bottom Line: Opportunity in Reset
The Great Housing Reset is creating a fundamentally different market than San Diego has experienced in 15 years. For homeowners who have grown accustomed to perpetual appreciation and rising rents, this adjustment requires a shift in thinking.
But resets also create opportunities. For sellers who need certainty in uncertain times, the cash buyer market offers a viable alternative to traditional sales that can drag on for months with uncertain outcomes.
For prospective buyers, the combination of stabilizing prices, increasing inventory, and gradually declining mortgage rates suggests improving conditions ahead—though patience may be required as the reset unfolds over the next several years.
The key is understanding that we're in a transition period. The old rules no longer apply, but the new equilibrium hasn't fully established itself yet. In this environment, flexibility, realistic expectations, and expert guidance become more valuable than ever.
Related Articles
San Diego Home Prices Fall for Sixth Consecutive Month in 2026
Case-Shiller data reveals continued price declines as San Diego diverges from national trends.
San Diego Housing Market Forecast 2026: Sell Now or Wait?
Analysis of whether to sell now or wait for appreciation in San Diego's shifting market.
Midway Rising: 4,254 Homes Transform Point Loma & Ocean Beach
How the massive Midway Rising development affects nearby neighborhoods and property values.
Cash Buyers' Advantage in San Diego's 2025 Housing Market
Why all-cash transactions dominate in uncertain markets and how they benefit sellers.